9 Comments

Wonderful piece! Many thanks.

I would quibble about "“communism was wholly discredited in Czechoslovakia after May 1968”.

Incompetence and, perhaps, cultural maladaptation were discredited. China has shown that a traditionally receptive, communalist culture with a competent bureaucracy like China's can make it work better than any system in history.

Expand full comment
author

Thanks for the kind words! I totally agree. To be sure, those are his sentiments, not mind. Need I make that more explicit?

Speaking very generally, I get the strong sense that people like Klaus whose lodestar is Cold War anti-communism and libertarianism simply cannot grasp that socialism might work in countries like China, Vietnam, and Cuba. The contradiction is simply too great.

I find it fascinating the way Mao (et al) merged the traditional culture of China (Confucianism + Daoism) with Marxism. If you haven't written about that much on your Substack, I hope you will!

Expand full comment

Good idea! Thanks.

Expand full comment

I worry that you omit the attacks against belief in God, as remarkably demonstrated, by the communists and now the liberals.

Expand full comment
author

Do you mean attacks on religious belief or attacks on the Church? The Bolsheviks suppressed the Orthodox Church because it was profoundly reactionary, ie, allied with the monarchy and aristocracy and hence posed a threat to the newly founded socialist state. Later, during WWII, Roosevelt pressured Stalin to rescind his suppression of the Church, and he did. One may not approve of the suppression of the Church, but one must admit that it in the past the commingling of spiritual and secular power has more often benefited the few than the many.

Expand full comment
Jun 9, 2023Liked by Colin Brace

Vauclav saw immediately that the 'climate crisis' was nonsense. He had the integrity to speak his mind. The Euro has done the southern Europeans no favours.

Expand full comment
author

Yeah, the whole net-zero thing is a giant scam. Green New Steal, we call it :) That isn't to say some kind of rational long-term post-carbon planning isn't needed, but this ain't that.

Since the euro was introduced, Italy has had ZERO growth; it has in effect been in a state of permanent stagnation and austerity for twenty years. How much longer will the Italians put up with this intolerable situation?

Expand full comment

I liked this article, but i will go further I see federalism as the steps to fascism

Expand full comment
author
Jun 12, 2023·edited Jun 12, 2023Author

Completely agree. I would only add that the fascism we are heading toward will obviously not look exactly like the fascism of the 1930s. Sheldon Wolin coined the term "inverted totalitarianism" to describe a system where the state serves corporate powers rather than the opposite, so as it was back then. Chris Hedges interviewed Wolin shortly before he died; highly recommended if you have the chance: https://presearch.com/search?q=youtube%20chris%20hedges%20sheldon%20wolin

Expand full comment